Owner Success Stories
Real Wyoming properties. Real results. Before and after numbers from owners in Sheridan, Dayton, Story, and Big Horn County. No projections. No estimates. Actual revenue.
Key Results
$42K peak annual revenue (3BR Dayton cabin)
71% peak occupancy achieved (3BR Dayton cabin)
88% year-round occupancy (downtown Sheridan apartment)
3 weeks average time from signed to live (all properties)
$131K combined annual revenue across 3 properties (Sheridan and Dayton)
Owner Stories
$42K/yr Revenue, Up From $18K
3BR Cabin, Dayton, Wyoming
$18,000/yr to $42,000/yr | 32% to 71% occupancy
"Wynder doubled our rental income in the first year. Their dynamic pricing alone paid for the management fee many times over."
We had a leaky faucet fixed the same morning it was reported, without the owner being called once.
Sarah M., Dayton, Wyoming
88% Occupancy Year-Round
Studio/1BR Apartment, Downtown Sheridan, Wyoming
40% to 88% occupancy
"My downtown apartment sits at 88% occupancy year-round. I never would have hit those numbers managing it myself."
WYO Rodeo week is fully booked six months ahead, every year. The property books consistently through the off-season too, something Amanda couldn't achieve on her own.
Amanda S., Downtown Sheridan, Wyoming
$34K/yr, First Check in 22 Days
Ranch Home, Dayton, Wyoming
$12,000/yr to $34,000/yr | 25% to 64% occupancy
"We live out of state and never worry about our property. They handle everything, and our monthly statements are always transparent."
Tom and Linda signed with Wynder and received their first check 22 days later. As out-of-state owners, they had struggled to keep the property occupied and maintained. Now they receive monthly statements and don't field a single maintenance call.
Tom & Linda K., Dayton, Wyoming
$55K/yr, Mountain Cabin in Story
Mountain Cabin, Story, Wyoming
$22,000/yr to $55,000/yr | 40% to 78% occupancy
"As a licensed brokerage, they operate at a level most property managers can't match. Our guests love the experience and keep coming back."
The property now earns more in summer peak than it previously earned in an entire year. Repeat guest bookings have become a significant share of the calendar, driven by the guest experience Wynder delivers on every stay.
Mike R., Story, Wyoming
$131K/yr Combined, 3 Properties
3 Properties, Sheridan and Dayton
$48,000/yr to $131,000/yr combined
"I now own three rentals and don't manage any of them. Wynder handles everything."
David added his second property after seeing the results on the first. Then a third. Combined revenue went from $48,000 to $131,000 per year. He has not managed a single booking, maintenance request, or guest message himself.
David R., Sheridan and Dayton
Guest Experiences
The Anniversary Trip of a Lifetime
The Pearl of Sheridan, Denver, CO
VRBO to Direct Booking
"From the concierge dinner to the horseback ride at sunrise, every detail was perfect. We booked the Airbnb version on our first trip and went direct the second time. Different experience entirely."
Emily and Jake switched from VRBO to booking direct at wyostays.com for their return visit. The direct booking saved them the platform service fee and gave them access to the Wynder concierge, which arranged the dinner reservation and the morning horseback ride.
Emily & Jake P., Denver, CO
A Family Reunion, 22 Guests, 3 Properties
3 Wynder Properties, Multi-generational Family
Direct Booking via wyostays.com
"We booked three houses for 22 people and the team made it seamless. One phone call, three properties coordinated, everyone happy."
One phone call coordinated three properties, staggered check-ins, and a group BBQ setup. The Henderson family had tried to organize a multi-property stay through Airbnb the year before and spent weeks on logistics. This time, Wynder handled all of it.
The Henderson Family
3 Weeks Working Remotely from Sheridan
Downtown Sheridan Apartment, San Francisco, CA
Direct Booking
"I worked remotely from Sheridan for three weeks. The team gave me restaurant picks, hiking trails, and checked in throughout. I felt completely taken care of."
Priya stayed three weeks with full concierge support for dining, trails, and local tips. Fast Wi-Fi, a dedicated workspace, and a walkable location two blocks from Main Street. She has already booked her return stay for next summer.
Priya N., San Francisco, CA
Ready to See These Results for Your Property?
Free income analysis. No commitment. Licensed Wyoming Brokerage.
Or call us: (307) 312-9656
Continue Exploring
Frequently Asked Questions
What areas does Wynder cover?
Wynder manages vacation rentals across Sheridan County, Wyoming, including downtown Sheridan, Story, Dayton, Big Horn, and Buffalo, plus the Bighorn Mountain corridor. Call (307) 312-9656 or browse the full collection at wyostays.com.
Is Wynder a licensed vacation rental company in Wyoming?
Yes. Wynder is a licensed, insured Wyoming real estate brokerage headquartered at 151 W Brundage St, Sheridan, Wyoming 82801. Wyoming law requires property managers to hold a real estate brokerage license. Wynder operates under this license.
How do I book direct and save with Wynder?
Book directly at wyostays.com or call (307) 312-9656. Booking direct means zero Airbnb or VRBO service fees. Same properties, same experience, lower price, with a licensed Wyoming brokerage backing the booking.